30 C
• zondag 24 september 2023

PBC | Postuum erepenning voor Jan Zwartendijk: de man die duizenden joodse levens redde met Curaçaose visa

Persbureau Curacao WILLEMSTAD – Demissionair premier Mark Rutte heeft afgelopen donderdag een erepenning voor Menslievend Hulpbetoon in goud uitgereikt aan de nabestaanden van Jan Zwartendijk. Zwartendijk, voormalig Philips-directeur...

PBC | Afvalkoningin Frouwkje Smit maakt Haute Couture uit Nederlands en Curaçaos’ afval

Persbureau Curacao AMSTERDAM – Kunstenaar Frouwkje Smit transformeert weggegooid afval in koninklijke Haute Couture. Als de Afvalkoningin gebruikt ze versleten paraplu’s, plastic zakken en meer om niet alleen...

ParadiseFM | Curaçao gezakt op Fifa ranglijst

Het Curaçaos voetbalelftal is gezakt op de Fifa ranking. Daar staat het nu op de 90e plaats. De selectie van interim-bondscoach verloor deze maand nog twee wedstrijden...

ParadiseFM | Kunneman weg bij VanEps

De bekende advocaat Frank Kunneman is zijn eigen kantoor begonnen. Dat meldt het Antilliaans Dagblad. Kunneman is na bijna een kwart eeuw niet langer werkzaam bij VanEps....

NTR | Jongeren helpen mee met koraalherstel

  Melissa Stamper Fundacion Parke Nacional Aruba (FPNA) wil het koraal op Aruba herstellen. Hiervoor worden de komende tijd 400 kunstrifstructuren in beschermde mariene gebieden geplaatst om meer onderwaterleven...

CC | Public Prosecution Service confirms ongoing criminal investigation into Ennia

WILLEMSTAD - The Public Prosecution Service has initiated a criminal investigation into the insurance company Ennia and individuals affiliated with Ennia. The report filed by the Central Bank...
- Advertisement -spot_img

DH | Claim against Venezuelan bankers involving Curaçao

HomeMediaDH | Claim against Venezuelan bankers involving Curaçao
Miami court rules Venezuelan $72 million fraud case can be brought in U.S.
$72 million fraud claim against Venezuelan bankers involving Curaçao

WILLEMSTAD–In a case with international political intrigue, a state appellate court in Miami resurrected a US $72 million theft claim against two Latin American bankers, including a top opponent of the late Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez.

The Third District Court of Appeal in Miami found that Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Jacqueline Hogan Scola should not have dismissed the case on forum grounds when she ruled the case should have been pursued in Curaçao.

The unanimous panel, with a specially concurring opinion by Chief Judge Frank A. Shepherd, found Scola “erroneously shifted the burden of proof regarding the viability of the alternative forum to the plaintiffs.” The opinion stems from the growing amount of Latin American litigationa brought in South Florida.

The plaintiffs are two powerful Venezuelan media companies: billboard company Publicidad Vepaco C.A. and television network LaTele Television C.A. The companies claim ex-bankers Nelson Mezerhane and Rogelio Trujillo stole and converted US $72 million in U.S. Treasury bills belonging to the plaintiffs through their Venezuelan bank, Banco Federal C.A., passing the money through three entities in Curaçao.

In 2009, the Venezuelan government took control of Banco Federal and took a controlling interest in Globovision, a 24-hour news station that was a Chavez opposition voice.

Mezerhane, the bank’s owner, also held a substantial stake in the media company. He and Trujillo fled to Florida before criminal charges were filed against them in Venezuela.

“I’m glad the court saw it our way and we will have a chance to take it to trial,” said attorney Rodolfo Sorondo Jr., a partner at Holland & Knight in Miami and a former appellate judge representing Vepaco and LaTele.

Sorondo noted Mezerhane didn’t find South Florida inconvenient to bring his federal lawsuit. The defendants argued to the DCA that the alleged harmful events occurred in Curaçao and therefore the island country has jurisdiction.

Mezerhane sought political asylum in the U.S. and filed a federal lawsuit in Miami against the Venezuelan government.

“As for the references to charges in Venezuela, the U.S. State Department granted my client asylum because of the persecution he faced in Venezuela. That speaks loud,” said Miami attorney Joseph DeMaria, a partner at Fox Rothschild who represents Mezerhane of Boca Raton.

Scola dismissed the most serious count, a civil theft claim, with prejudice. That decision was not appealed and stands, DeMaria said.

South Miami attorney Henry Bell, who represents ex-bank CEO Trujillo, said if the DCA decision stands, it will make Florida taxpayers carry the burden of adjudicating numerous disputes stemming from facts and businesses with little or no connection to the state.

“It’s bad enough for Mr. Trujillo that he was run out of his country because of its political upheaval. He is a victim,” Bell said. “He did not commit any fraud upon anyone and we will contest any claim or suggestion otherwise.”

Judge Leslie Rothenberg wrote the majority opinion. Judge Kevin Emas concurred. The appellate court heard arguments in November 2013.

Rothenberg said the “harmful events” allegedly occurred in Venezuela, not Curaçao where the T-bills allegedly were misappropriated. “It is uncertain whether the courts in the alternative forum (Curaçao) will have the subject matter jurisdiction over the litigation,” she wrote.

Rothenberg said the trial court made other rulings that would cost the plaintiffs time and money if Curaçao ended up denying jurisdiction.

In his concurring opinion, Shepherd said the defendants’ position that Florida presented “relative disadvantages” didn’t pass the “proverbial straight-face test.” He said there appeared to be material witnesses in Florida, including former officers and directors of Banco Federal, who could be called at trial.

“The defendants, who live in Florida, are the alleged architects of the fraud,” Shepherd wrote. “Their testimony alone should be sufficient to acquit themselves of the alleged fraud, if a defence there be.”

DeMaria said for an appellate judge to make such a statement is troubling because there has been no fraud evidence presented. “They are mere allegations of a plaintiff,” he said. “I don’t think any judge should be pre-judging this case.”

Shepherd said he reluctantly joined the majority, stating the only connection for the defendants is Florida residence. “They reside here as a matter of grace, growing out of political upheaval in their own country,” he wrote. “The courts of this state have no obligation, legal or otherwise, to supplement the federal munificence being received by them.”

DeMaria said the concurrence reads more like a dissent. “He is inviting us to go to the Florida Supreme Court on this,” DeMaria said.

LaTele has been making legal news of late in South Florida, bringing a high-profile copyright infringement lawsuit against Telemundo Telecommunications Group, claiming the Spanish-language network in Hialeah stole the premise of its telenovela (soap opera) “Maria Maria” for the show “El Rostro de Analia.”

Bron: DailyHerald

Geef een reactie

Vul alstublieft uw commentaar in!
Vul hier uw naam in


Recente reacties